Posts

The best thing to do in business is to learn from the mistakes of others. Here are three major lessons learned from some of the biggest business blunders to ever occur:

Mistake #1: Ignoring their own innovations

We all know Xerox, they’re world famous for their document solutions and services. Your company is probably using several of their machines. What you might not know is that they could’ve owned the entire computer industry if they had the foresight to.

Back in the day, in 1970 to be exact, Xerox set up the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC) to invent the technology of the future. They pumped it with funding and made sure the genius scientists working there had everything they needed to make magic.

And magic they made.

PARC invented what is widely argued to be the world’s first Personal Computer in 1973.

The Xerox Alto was awesome — it had an operating system, the world’s first Graphical User Interface (GUI — which enabled the then primitive computer screens to display information beyond just numbers and letters), and even a mouse to point towards stuff on the screen. To top it all off, this computer was linked to other PCs by a system they created called the ethernet.

No other machine had this magical combo at the time.

Remember, this was before Apple, Microsoft and the likes even came up with anything close to what Xerox had invented.

And what did Xerox do with this amazing breakthrough technology?

Nothing (much).

The higher ups didn’t quite get the revolutionary technology they had in their hands. They were more focused on their photocopiers that were the existing cash cow of the company.

According to former PARC researcher Larry Tessler,

“the company management at the East Coast of the USA did not (care a straw for) the PARC’s research results unless they were directly involved with photocopiers.”

Someone else was there to capitalize from this technology though.

Steve Jobs was invited to take a tour of the PARC facility in 1979. And during this tour they were introduced to the Xerox Alto and all its (at the time) jaw-dropping tech.

As Larry Tesler demonstrated how their “mouse” moves the cursor on the screen and clicked on icons, opened and closed “windows”, wrote emails to other people in PARC, Steve Jobs gradually got more and more excited.

In Steve Jobs’ own words:

“Why aren’t you doing anything with this? This is the greatest thing. This is revolutionary!”

He took this inspiration back to Apple and the rest, as you know, was history.

 

Mistake #2: Not looking beyond their existing business models

Image source: gizmodo.com

In the early 2000s, Blockbuster was the kingpin of the video rental industry in the United States. At its prime in 2004, it had about 60,000 employees and over 2,000 stores in 25 countries.

Just a short 6 years later, Blockbuster filed for bankruptcy.

Why?

Here’s a fun little story about Blockbuster and Netflix you may have heard.

Back in 2000, Reed Hastings, founder of the then tiny, but thriving company called Netflix, met up with Blockbuster CEO John Antioco and his team.

Hastings suggested they join forces and work together. The deal was that Netflix would help run Blockbuster’s online service while Blockbuster helps run Netflix’s offline component (DVD rental through their large network of stores).

Netflix was laughed out of the room.

We don’t know what would’ve happened if they ended up partnering with Netflix. Would Netflix have grown into what they are today — a 61 billion dollar company? Not too sure.

What we do know is that Blockbuster had the funds, the expertise and the resources to launch their own subscription-based streaming service, but they didn’t.

They even got an offer to purchase Netflix for $50 million, but they didn’t.

Instead, they continued focusing on their existing business model — physical stores that rent out videos.

Because they ran such a large network of stores and employed so many people — they needed DVD rental prices that could sustain this. A significant chunk of their profit also came from late fees, something which doesn’t even exist on mail-order video rental services like Netflix.

It was OK when they were the main player, but when given a better alternative and better customer experience?

Netflix knew what the customer wanted — variety and convenience at a low price. They also accurately predicted the customer’s shifting priorities when online streaming became more accessible.

Because they saw that, they pivoted quickly from their mail-order business into an intuitive online platform for movie-watching.

At a time when similar sites were struggling to even display their content in a clean, functional manner, Netflix was sleek, sexy and even had a first-of-its-kind system which accurately recommended movies based on what your personal preferences and movie-consumption history.

Blockbuster’s CEO Antioco realized Netflix (and other services like it) was becoming a threat. And in 2004, he started taking action — he discontinued the late fees and pumped money into a digital platform which he hoped would pave the way to Blockbuster’s bright future.

The board of directors were not happy about the $400 million these moves would cost the company. They did not believe that growing an online business and finding new ways to satisfy customers were the right strategy to take.

In 2007, they fired Antioco and reinstated the late fees. They raised prices on Blockbuster’s digital platform and cut marketing on it despite its fast growth rate. Instead of innovating their business model, they chose to focus on their brick-and-mortar business.

Wrong move.

Today, the Blockbuster brand has mostly vanished from society, with a few straggling stores scattered in certain markets. Netflix, on the other hand, has become a household name.

In his reflections on this, Antioco wrote in the Harvard Business Review that he “firmly believed that if our online strategy had not been essentially abandoned, Blockbuster Online would have 10 million subscribers today, and we’d be rivaling Netflix for the leadership position in the internet downloading business.”

Quite possible, indeed.

 

Mistake #3: Not changing fast enough

Image source: REUTERS/Kacper Pempel

Just over a decade ago, Nokia defined the mobile phone industry. With a history that began in 1979, it innovated its way into making the most sought-after mobile phones in the market. It was the world’s no. 1 phone company and sold its billionth phone in 2005.

Shortly after, iPhones and Android came into the market. Suddenly, consumers weren’t looking at Nokia anymore for the latest and greatest in mobile tech.

When Android 1.0 was launched in 2008, Nokia’s Q3 profits plummeted by 30%. It went downhill from there.

Nokia realized a bit too late in the game that they needed something that could compete with the smartphones being produced by Apple, Blackberry and Samsung and the likes.

While Nokia continued releasing solid phones with top-notch build quality, the Symbian software that they used in their touch-enabled phones were sub-par compared to Apple and Android phones. Nokia was making great quality phones with amazing cameras, but lagged behind in user experience.

People found other mobile phone operating systems easier to use and so sales continued to dip.

In a last-ditch attempt to win the smartphone battle, Nokia partnered with Microsoft to produce phone that will run on a Windows OS.

The move sold quite a few phones, but it came too slow, and the end product was not good enough to compete with the likes of Apple and Android phones which still delivered a far superior user experience.

Nokia’s market share continued to decline and in 2014, Microsoft acquired Nokia’s mobile business for $7.2 billion.

Just for a bit of perspective, at the height of its times in 2000, Nokia’s market cap was hovering around $245 billion.

However, this is fortunately not the end of the story.

There’s talk of a comeback for Nokia in the first half of 2017, and this time finally, the phones will run on Android. Knowing Nokia’s hardware capabilities, I’m definitely looking forward to see what they come up with.

______

What are the biggest mistakes you’ve made in business and what has that cost you? Share your lessons in the comments section below.

 

The word “innovation” might be an overused buzzword in today’s business world, but there’s no denying that fresh value-creating ideas can open up new revenue streams and customer bases which could determine the future of your company.

This is probably why so many companies are scrambling to build an innovative culture. Unfortunately, not all companies have got it down pat. According to a McKinsey survey, 84% of executives agree that innovation is important to their growth strategy, but only 6% are satisfied with their innovation performance.

Why? It’s simple. They haven’t found what works.

There are many factors which come into play when you want to innovate. But perhaps one of the biggest bedrocks for innovation is the right company culture.

So how does one create an innovative company culture?

The people who know best are of course the people who do it the most. We had a quick chat with industry leaders — both startups and the big boys — to see how they steer their companies towards innovation.

Read on to get insights from:

Brage Johansen, CEO of Zaptec — one of the most forward-looking Norwegian tech companies with a space program.

Rafiq Razali, CEO of Media Prima Digital — Malaysia’s largest fully-integrated media company.

Greg Paull, Co-Founder of R3 — a global consultancy which works with the world’s top marketers.

Shakira Shanaz, Head of Operations of KFit Group — Southeast Asia’s fastest growing online-to-offline platform.

Wai Hong Fong, Co-Founder of Storehub — a cloud-based retail management system that has revolutionized the retail market in Malaysia and beyond.

Jessica Li, Co-Founder of dahmakan — the fastest growing food tech startup in Southeast Asia.

 

 

brage johansenBrage Johansen

CEO

 Zaptec

Brage Johansen is the CEO of Zaptec, a Norwegian tech company which, in just 3 years, has revolutionized the global electric mobility industry with their patented portfolio of solutions for supercompact power electronics and transformers.

Having the ability to pack so much power in an incredibly tiny package has enabled Zaptec to explore any industry where power plays a significant role. Zaptec is now transforming solar power, electric vehicle-charging, infrastructure, aviation and space exploration across the globe.

In 2016, Zaptec launched three new products — including ZapCharger, the world’s first portable charging station for electric vehicles, and ZapSafety, the world’s first supercompact isolation transformer for the industrial safety market.

They are also collaborating with NASA and ESA to develop their core technology for operations on asteroids and drilling on Mars.

So how does Zaptec, a company with a space program and plans to conquer space drive innovation?

Three major factors drive innovation within Zaptec:

1. A long-term vision and technology plan

This plan shows how we want to improve and change the world’s electric infrastructure, in all industries.

2. Vigorous network expansion

We systematically increase our network, public outreach and number of Zappers (groupies), which again stimulates Zaptec’s innovation process with ideas and support.

3.  A supportive organisational structure

To give room to innovation, we have organised our activities in daughter companies that can evolve separately.

Zaptec Charger (ZC) is responsible for all products on charging electric cars and building massive charging infrastructures. ZC has a strict focus on sales and finishing the engineering around these products. The creative force now lies with Zaptec Power (ZP), which is developing next generation Zaptechnology and exploring many new markets.

We found it very beneficial to divide innovative forces and focus on different daughter companies.

While we do not have any structured methods or meetings to stimulate innovations, we found it important to create an environment where innovation can happen.

We have a culture of open communication, humor and creativity so that ideas within the Zaptec architecture can flourish. We use Slack to share articles, opinions, ideas and customer feedback within our teams.

 

rafiq razaliRafiq Razali

CEO

 Media Prima Digital

Rafiq Razali is the CEO of Media Prima Digital — the digital arm of Media Prima Berhad, Malaysia’s largest fully-integrated media company with equity interests in television stations, newspapers, radio stations and digital media.

It operates Malaysia’s 4 leading free-to-air TV stations, some of the country’s most popular radio stations and also owns Malaysia’s largest publisher with 3 national newspapers.

Media Prima Digital manages the online operations for all the TV and radio networks under Media Prima and is charged with the long-term growth of the group as traditional print media circulation declines.

Innovation wasn’t a key focus for the Media Prima Group as it was the biggest player of its kind in the Malaysian media market and did not have to innovate much to grow.

However, digital disruption and a poor economy the past couple of years has spurred Media Prima Group to really start changing the way they operate.

Aiming for a bigger presence in digital, the Group has launched Media Prima Labs, an in-house incubator for innovation which produces new digital products and services.

Media Prima Labs has launched 8 apps to date and will be launching another 5 in the coming months. The apps have garnered over 1 million downloads to date, which was double what the team had expected.

How does Malaysia’s leading digital media group drive innovation?

The key ingredients to me are the 3 things I live by at work, which are:

  1. Control the controllables
  2. Always start from the customer
  3. Great people make great companies

It’s the same when it comes to driving a high innovation culture.

Right now, what we are focusing on is to:

Over-Communicate

This is so that the team understands what we want to do and what their roles are in this transformation, and to also manage stakeholders not in the team so that we get their support to continue.

Encourage Conversation, Even with Top Management

We encourage people in the team to speak up or provide feedback at all times.

Some of our projects are driven from top down, but we do have a couple that has started from the team. For instance we are now working on an app that’ll help us sell our billboard inventories better. That was the brainchild of someone from our team, and it immediately got the buy-in from everyone.

He was passionate about it and did a mock-up of the product on his own time. One day he just came up to me and presented it. I thought it was great, so I made the necessary arrangements to push it through.

Create a Supportive Environment for Projects to Succeed

We really incubate our projects. We create a support environment so that our projects can flourish (the eco system of marketing, tech, design, data etc), but also allow the project manager enough autonomy to just do what needs to be done to improve the product.

This means that we continue even if the product cannibalizes an existing business, is “off-brand”, or any other form of corporate red tape. To ensure that innovation happens, the initiatives that are run needs to be protected.

Align the Goals of Project Managers with the Support Structures

We assign each project to a project manager, but we ensure that they get all the help they need from a marketing, tech, data etc standpoint. The support structures’ goals are also aligned with the goals of the project manager, so collaboration is a lot smoother. This ensures that the project manager can spend as much time as possible improving & innovating the product.

 

 

greg paullGreg Paull

Co-Founder

R3 Worldwide

Greg Paull is the Co-Founder and Principal of R3 Worldwide — a global consultancy focused on improving the effectiveness and efficiency of marketers and their agencies.

The most experienced consultancy of its kind, R3 has offices across the globe, with over 100 employees in the US, Asia, Europe as well as Latin America.

R3 currently works with some of the world’s top marketers, including Coca-Cola, Unilever, AB InBev, MasterCard, Mercedes Benz, Johnson & Johnson, Samsung, and Kimberly Clark.

So how does a company with employees across the globe drive cross-border innovation?

We try to do a couple of things well —

Weekly sharing

Every week our teams share best practices with each other in a formal Tuesday Sharing session locally. Everyone gives feedback and that builds the learning curve. The presentation decks are then shared across our offices. Once a year, the entire global team flies into a city for three days of knowledge sharing.

“Can Do” Award

Once a month we pay a bonus to a team of individuals who go above and beyond — people that have used their own initiatives and broken the rules, gone the extra mile, or done something exceptional.

Global office transfers

For a small company, we work hard on moving talent around. Seven of our US team came from Shanghai. Our best researcher in Singapore came from R3 Vietnam. A new talent in R3 Beijing moved from R3 Shanghai. Our best analyst in London moved from R3 Singapore. We work under a single global profit & loss statement so there are no barriers to driving this movement.

It’s pretty simple — companies won’t hire us unless we can help them lead at innovation. It’s not something we can do “by the way”, it’s something that has to be the core of our DNA to fuel growth. Today, half our revenue is linked to digital — up from 25% three years ago. It’s because we want to make a difference. See how we’ve helped HSBC innovate digitally here.

 

 

 

shakira shanazShakira Shanaz

Head of Operations

 KFit Group

KFit Group is the fastest growing online-to-offline (o2o) local commerce company in Southeast Asia and Hong Kong. Beginning in 2015 as a fitness sharing platform, it has since expanded its offerings to include restaurants, beauty & wellness, lifestyle and more.

In August this year, KFit Group acquired Groupon Indonesia, and in November, Groupon Malaysia, with a goal to innovate and localize, to succeed where Groupon US failed. Since it was acquired by KFit Group, Groupon Indonesia has achieved a growth of nearly 2x, according to KFit Group CEO Joel Neoh.

Moving so fast and decisively, how does KFit Group drive innovation?

As an organisation, we always work with end-goals in mind, and with everyone 100% focused on achieving them.

If we realize midway that we need to restructure our goals, either because of evolving business needs, or if we find a better way to approach things, we adapt accordingly.

We stop, brainstorm, align on the new way forward, and start executing.

I think in some ways this is how Fave, our O2O local commerce platform came about. Basically, we wanted to offer customers the same value proposition as we did for KFit, but across new verticals including dining, health and beauty, and entertainment.

As a fast-growing, local e-commerce company, we need to make sure we’re nimble but focused on what is is we are trying to achieve.

At the end of the day, it’s important to remember that change is constant, but it’s up to us to find the most effective solution to each and every challenge.

Employ Great, Diverse People

I always believe that behind every great company, there are great people who are aligned towards organisational goals.

We’re lucky to have a solid team of people who each bring with them a wealth of experience — having previously worked in a variety of roles, industries, and countries.

We feel this diversity is one of the more ‘natural’ ways to foster innovation. We’ve also divided some teams, like our engineering and product team, into smaller, autonomous squads. This allows each team to have total ownership and responsibility over every aspect of the product they’re working on.

Open Up the Floor for Ideas

At the same time, we really encourage independent thinking and problem solving within the team. We open the floor to anyone who wants to contribute their ideas, which is a great way for people to learn.

I remember there was once an intern here, who, on his second day with us, had some great ideas on how our app could be better. We had him discuss it directly with our CTO, and many of his suggestions were worked into our product pipeline. This is the kind of synergy we encourage at KFit group.

 

wai hong fongWai Hong Fong

Co-Founder

StoreHub

Wai Hong Fong is the co-founder of StoreHub, a cloud-based retail management system that replaces bulky and clunky cash registers with an iPad POS. The space-efficient system not only looks sleek and sexy, but comes packed with power and enables store owners manage their inventory, customer relationships and data in real time.

Founded in 2013, StoreHub’s innovative system has revolutionized the retail market in Malaysia and is now currently serves customers in over 12 countries.

How does a hyper-paced startup like StoreHub drive innovation?

Innovation is a result of two mindsets existing together.

The first is the freedom to engage new ideas.

At StoreHub we have a strong culture of giving positive affirmation to people when they try new things and fail, while giving negative affirmation when we see behavior that is ‘permission seeking’.

Our only caveat is that things be given sufficient thought. We also do not give weight to ideas based on who shares it i.e. positional influence but we give weight to ideas based on the merit of their reasoning.

The second mindset is a drive to constantly make things better.

Every new employee at Storehub will be reminded that their responsibility is not to simply work in(side) a process, but to also work on a process.

What this means is that if you’re in marketing, you’re not just following the manual to do your job, but you’re encouraged to find ways to make that ‘manual’ better.

When you combine both the freedom of idea generation and execution with the mindset of ongoing improvement, we find that people naturally find new ways to do old things and new things to embark on. This for us is innovation in action.

When we talk about making the lives of others better, innovation is key. New ideas alone don’t become meaningful until they partner with a real desire to improve things.

The future of StoreHub relies heavily on building teams that carry a healthy amount of both mindsets simply because that is where real value is created. A company that does not constantly seek to create more and more value will eventually fail to exist.

 

jessica liJessica Li

Co-Founder, COO

 dahmakan

In 2014, Jessica Li co-founded Malaysian healthy food delivery service, dahmakan, to address the gap in the industry for healthy and affordable lunch options. Beginning with just 5 orders a day, dahmakan is now the fastest growing food tech startup in SouthEast Asia, backed by angel investors and is in talks with global venture capital firms.

Meaning “have you eaten” in Malay, dahmakan is revolutionizing the health food industry in Malaysia. By developing their own logistics technology, they managed to significant expand their delivery area which now covers 80% of the Klang Valley — opening up a customer base of over 8 million.
Dah Makan aims to democratize high quality food the same way Ikea has democratised designer furniture.

So how does dahmakan, competing in the fast-moving space of F&B, drive innovation?

As a food tech startup, we don’t think about “innovation” as a function or strategy. Instead, dahmakan was born with the intention to create something new and to do things differently. Like a jigsaw puzzle player, we use the best practices and knowledge of different industries and combine them in a new way. Most of the time, the jigsaw pieces don’t fully fit so we have to slightly change their shape or in some cases completely reinvent them.

Keep testing, trying and improving

We try out and implement technology across every function e.g. to build a fully automated delivery system that makes decisions in real time with high efficiencies. Using machine learning and advanced technology, we have built a system that caters to on-demand orders at a third of the cost of traditional food delivery. We place high focus on our R&D team that compromises of ex-developers from Google, Stanford marketing talents and even 5-star chefs that are constantly working towards new innovations.

Create a conducive space

At dahmakan, we encourage ideation and cross-function discussion among teams to come up with new solutions by having an open plan space with mingled seating.

Celebrate both victories and failures

When an amazing idea surfaces, the individual is then given the responsibilities of executing the idea.

Ideas are great, but its all about fast execution and learning along the way. We encourage employees by making sure there isn’t a wrong or right approach until you execute it and we celebrate both victories and failures as a source of ongoing learning.

Share knowledge

Another weekly initiative is our “Knowledge Flower” session where employees share their past experience and knowledge with other employees based on topics relevant to the organisation.

Set Clear Goals

Lastly, we use an Objectives and Key Results (OKR)-based goal setting system. Everyone’s individual OKR hangs on the wall in the office. This includes all founders and top management OKRs in order to enhance transparency and encourage exchange of ideas as well as to stretch everyone’s thinking.
_____
How does your company drive innovation? Share your insights with us in the comments section below.

_____

Sometimes it’s hard to communicate your vision for innovation. Visual strategy tools help get your team on the same page when it comes to new ideas and implementation. Check out the Strategy Tools World Tour.

You’ve probably had an idea or two that was shot down by those around you. Too unrealistic. Doesn’t suit the market. Too much work to be feasible. Too “out-of-the-box”.

We’ve all been there. We’ve all had second, or maybe even third thoughts about our brilliant plans for the future. But if there’s anything to be learned from history, it’s to never let the doubters and naysayers get you down.

If you believe enough in your idea and work at it, you will definitely make it a reality in the future. Good luck, and stick to it!

a-brief-history-of-doubters-infographic

What quotes from your doubters would you like to change in the future? Let us know in the comments below, and prove them wrong!